Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
Moderator: Panzer Corps 2 Moderators
-
- Sergeant - 7.5 cm FK 16 nA
- Posts: 216
- Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2015 5:15 am
Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
Besides the interface, is there any meaningful differences?
I'm asking because, i'm wondering if i will simply play more or less the same game with a different interface.
i got over 1000 hours into PzC I.
Thanks.
I'm asking because, i'm wondering if i will simply play more or less the same game with a different interface.
i got over 1000 hours into PzC I.
Thanks.
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
It wouldn't be a sequel if it wasn't similar to the original game.
That said, there are many mechanical improvements and changes to the gameplay that add a lot of variety to gameplay. Especially encirclement and surrender mechanics.
These short clips do a good job highlight a few of the interesting new mechanics that elevate Panzer Corps 2 above the original, while still being true to the core concepts of the original.
viewtopic.php?f=464&t=97198
That said, there are many mechanical improvements and changes to the gameplay that add a lot of variety to gameplay. Especially encirclement and surrender mechanics.
These short clips do a good job highlight a few of the interesting new mechanics that elevate Panzer Corps 2 above the original, while still being true to the core concepts of the original.
viewtopic.php?f=464&t=97198
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
I would say it's much better. A few of the changes:
- Combat has been reworked, there is now a separate to hit mechanic. This makes much more sense and has a huge difference on experience and armor calculations in particular. A green tiger tank will just miss a lot, whereas an elite M3 Stuart still wont be able to penetrate heavy armor.
- Most unit classes have been rebalanced. Examples are: AT now provides defensive fire support, recon adds a bonus to neighbouring units, infantry has 15 strength.
- Encirclement is now in the game. You can now attempt to surround enemy units.
- The slots system has been reworked so that not all units require 1 slot. Weaker units require less. This allows you to balance out a few powerful units or more weaker ones.
These changes make for a significantly more enjoyable game in my experience.
- Combat has been reworked, there is now a separate to hit mechanic. This makes much more sense and has a huge difference on experience and armor calculations in particular. A green tiger tank will just miss a lot, whereas an elite M3 Stuart still wont be able to penetrate heavy armor.
- Most unit classes have been rebalanced. Examples are: AT now provides defensive fire support, recon adds a bonus to neighbouring units, infantry has 15 strength.
- Encirclement is now in the game. You can now attempt to surround enemy units.
- The slots system has been reworked so that not all units require 1 slot. Weaker units require less. This allows you to balance out a few powerful units or more weaker ones.
These changes make for a significantly more enjoyable game in my experience.
-
- Sergeant - 7.5 cm FK 16 nA
- Posts: 216
- Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2015 5:15 am
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
Thanks for the feedback.
I'm a bit worried because back in time, i loved panzer general 1 and 2 but hated panzer general 3.
I'm a bit worried because back in time, i loved panzer general 1 and 2 but hated panzer general 3.
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
Most people did. Panzer Corps (1) and Panzer Corps (2) are both good games and worthy successors of the first two Panzer General games. PC1 is more like PG1, but better in many ways and incorporates many aspects (like heroes) that were only introduced in PG2. PC2 continues that progression and I strongly believe will continue to get better, like PC1 did, with time, updates, and additional DLCs.JagdpanzerIV wrote: ↑Tue Aug 18, 2020 5:05 am Thanks for the feedback.
I'm a bit worried because back in time, i loved panzer general 1 and 2 but hated panzer general 3.
Keep playing PC1 until you've had your fill, and then move on to PC2 afterwards if you're hungering for more.
-
- Lieutenant Colonel - Panther D
- Posts: 1267
- Joined: Wed Jun 04, 2014 7:44 pm
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
On top of what has been mentioned... the 'Developers' are making earnest effort's to take out some of the 'Repetitive-Dreary-Drudgery' out of this WWII Epic by giving us some sideline shows like... "The Civil War In Spain"..."Czechoslovakia"... "The Saar-Offensive" and such-like to make the Game seem more new and refreshing instead of re-doing or following the same old-rote or play-book that usually accompanies a featured War-Game like this.
PzC2 will enhance your experience and understanding of the European War in ways that you are not likely to get anywhere else!.
PzC2 will enhance your experience and understanding of the European War in ways that you are not likely to get anywhere else!.
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
Panzer Corps definitely feels more like Panzer General.
Panzer Corps 2 feels more like Panzer General 2.
Personally, I am totally on board with this.
Years ago when I was actively playing PG and PG2, I would always revisit PG for the nostalgia hit... which would near instantly wear off once you actually play it. And then I put that game right back down.
PG2 is the game I would revisit, and then actually play and replay extensively. PG2 also had a lot of extra content, which Panzer Corps 2 is just starting to roll out.
That said, some PG2 campaigns were very underwhelming. I think the Soviet campaign was like 6 scenarios? Imagine if Panzer Corps 2 shipped with Allied campaigns of that length. I think people would be more mad than not having them at all, which they already are displeased with.
Panzer Corps 2 feels more like Panzer General 2.
Personally, I am totally on board with this.
Years ago when I was actively playing PG and PG2, I would always revisit PG for the nostalgia hit... which would near instantly wear off once you actually play it. And then I put that game right back down.
PG2 is the game I would revisit, and then actually play and replay extensively. PG2 also had a lot of extra content, which Panzer Corps 2 is just starting to roll out.
That said, some PG2 campaigns were very underwhelming. I think the Soviet campaign was like 6 scenarios? Imagine if Panzer Corps 2 shipped with Allied campaigns of that length. I think people would be more mad than not having them at all, which they already are displeased with.
-
- Lieutenant Colonel - Panther D
- Posts: 1267
- Joined: Wed Jun 04, 2014 7:44 pm
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
"KERENSKY!!!"...while you're here discussing "PG2"... you are "The-One" that just might be in the know as to where one could 'Download' revisit and play that old-Game!. I still have the 'Original-Disks'... but... alas... cannot get those old programs to work with the updated 'Windows-Version'.Kerensky wrote: ↑Tue Aug 18, 2020 8:08 pm Panzer Corps definitely feels more like Panzer General.
Panzer Corps 2 feels more like Panzer General 2.
Personally, I am totally on board with this.
Years ago when I was actively playing PG and PG2, I would always revisit PG for the nostalgia hit... which would near instantly wear off once you actually play it. And then I put that game right back down.
PG2 is the game I would revisit, and then actually play and replay extensively. PG2 also had a lot of extra content, which Panzer Corps 2 is just starting to roll out.
That said, some PG2 campaigns were very underwhelming. I think the Soviet campaign was like 6 scenarios? Imagine if Panzer Corps 2 shipped with Allied campaigns of that length. I think people would be more mad than not having them at all, which they already are displeased with.
Any assistance or guidance would surely be welcome!.
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
https://www.gog.com/game/panzer_general_2
Those 'old discs' are just too old I think. I keep my old PG2 box because it's awesome to have the actual game box.. but that's about all it's worth really. The contents inside are too out of date to be of actual use.
Those 'old discs' are just too old I think. I keep my old PG2 box because it's awesome to have the actual game box.. but that's about all it's worth really. The contents inside are too out of date to be of actual use.
-
- Field Marshal - Elefant
- Posts: 5847
- Joined: Mon Aug 15, 2011 12:48 pm
- Location: the land of freedom
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
The PG2 hand-painted maps were amazing.
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
Open General is a freeware 'upgrade of PG2' , plays PG2 campaigns as well as new OG campaigns.Retributarr wrote: ↑Tue Aug 18, 2020 8:42 pm "KERENSKY!!!"...while you're here discussing "PG2"... you are "The-One" that just might be in the know as to where one could 'Download' revisit and play that old-Game!. I still have the 'Original-Disks'... but... alas... cannot get those old programs to work with the updated 'Windows-Version'.
Any assistance or guidance would surely be welcome!.
Just DuckDuckGo 'Open General'. It was a free rival to PGF in 2009, PGF is a pay upgrade to PzC.
OG is still being upgraded, PGF is not.
There comes a time on every project when it is time to shoot the engineer and ship the damn thing.
-
- Field Marshal - Elefant
- Posts: 5847
- Joined: Mon Aug 15, 2011 12:48 pm
- Location: the land of freedom
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
If PGF=Panzer General Forever then it's FREE !
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
Typo, should be:
PzC is a pay upgrade to PGF.
Yes both PGF and OG are freeware.
There comes a time on every project when it is time to shoot the engineer and ship the damn thing.
-
- Sergeant - 7.5 cm FK 16 nA
- Posts: 216
- Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2015 5:15 am
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
Thank you guys, i will give it a try after i'm done with pathfinder kingmaker
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
Well , I never actually played Panzer Corps I ....JagdpanzerIV wrote: ↑Thu Aug 13, 2020 8:12 pm Besides the interface, is there any meaningful differences?
But I cannot resist here a personal anecdote ;
Did Panzer Corps I have a dedicated , fully - fleshed - out , Spanish Civil War DLC / expansion ? With the practical possibility of putting your Germans in Trubia tanks or Bilbao armored cars ? Or of equipping your Germans with Russian tanks and Russian howitzers ? Did your Stuka's begin their careers as Junkers Ju 87 A's , or even as Henschel Hs 123's ? Did you get to play with Spanish Nationalists , AND Italians , along with your Germans , and all at the same time ?
For that matter , did Panzer Corps I have fascinating AA gun and recon mechanics , that make investing in AA guns and recon units absolutely worth the while ?
Did it have camos , insignias , and heroes , which double the personalization and role-play aspects of your core units ?
In Panzer Corps 2 , it also appears we will be having some kind of funny business in Czechoslovakia and Denmark too !
( Czechoslovakia and Denmark as official content ??? Germans in Trubia tanks as official content ??? You mean I don't need a modding work - around for this neat , eccentric stuff ??? )
And the game only launched this March !
By the way , I had no idea when I bought the Field Marshall edition that the first expansion would be the Spanish Civil War ; my hearts desire !
For a game that only launched this March , I already rate Panzer Corps 2 as the best investment I ever made in a war game since Avalon Hill's " Jutland ".
Which is to say that , for me at least , Panzer Corps 2 is absolutely top drawer !
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
I feel there are so many interesting game mechanics added that gives it so much more opportunities.JagdpanzerIV wrote: ↑Thu Aug 13, 2020 8:12 pm Besides the interface, is there any meaningful differences?
I'm asking because, i'm wondering if i will simply play more or less the same game with a different interface.
i got over 1000 hours into PzC I.
Thanks.
The new heroes alone... I don't know if I even got one of each so far.
The general traits and weaknesses
Mechanisms for big encirclements.
Buffs and more specializations for unit types - especially AT guns are so much more improved. Units are more balanced (though I shed some tears here, no more endless instant kills with my overpowered 5-star 15 strenght 8.8
Other than PzC 1 so far I think the DLCs don't live up to the Vanilla campaign yet, but I am fully convinced we will get there.
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
Same, but I dont get the PG3 vibe from PC2.JagdpanzerIV wrote: ↑Tue Aug 18, 2020 5:05 am Thanks for the feedback.
I'm a bit worried because back in time, i loved panzer general 1 and 2 but hated panzer general 3.
I really like the customisation that the Heroes give you.
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
Yeah, weren't the UK and US campaigns basically the same just with different voice-acting in PG2?Kerensky wrote: ↑Tue Aug 18, 2020 8:08 pm Panzer Corps definitely feels more like Panzer General.
Panzer Corps 2 feels more like Panzer General 2.
Personally, I am totally on board with this.
Years ago when I was actively playing PG and PG2, I would always revisit PG for the nostalgia hit... which would near instantly wear off once you actually play it. And then I put that game right back down.
PG2 is the game I would revisit, and then actually play and replay extensively. PG2 also had a lot of extra content, which Panzer Corps 2 is just starting to roll out.
That said, some PG2 campaigns were very underwhelming. I think the Soviet campaign was like 6 scenarios? Imagine if Panzer Corps 2 shipped with Allied campaigns of that length. I think people would be more mad than not having them at all, which they already are displeased with.
Honestly, as someone who loved PG1, I've always found the way that PG2 (and also Pacific General which had similar problems) got praised kind of confusing. Like I've said elsewhere, bad AI is one thing, but the AI literally not moving its artillery at all is a game-breaker as it makes the AI incapable of sustaining an offensive. Did everyone just play multi-player and not play against the AI? Also, PG2 had a few too many puzzler-like "reach objective X by turn Y" missions where it felt like the AI was AFK.
What was the problem with PG3? I remember reading people complaining about the AI moves being scripted but this doesn't seem like such a problem.
-
- Sergeant - 7.5 cm FK 16 nA
- Posts: 214
- Joined: Wed Oct 31, 2012 9:19 pm
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
As I remember (OLD memories!), my main issue with PG3 & Peoples General were very low unit densities. Really brought out the puzzle game aspect, since you had so few units there really wasn't much of an option to win using different tactics. Kinda like playing tic-tac-toe as far as tactical options. While my memories are vague, I didn't care for any of the sequels after PG2 (and I bought them all).FOARP wrote: ↑Wed Aug 26, 2020 11:20 amYeah, weren't the UK and US campaigns basically the same just with different voice-acting in PG2?Kerensky wrote: ↑Tue Aug 18, 2020 8:08 pm Panzer Corps definitely feels more like Panzer General.
Panzer Corps 2 feels more like Panzer General 2.
Personally, I am totally on board with this.
Years ago when I was actively playing PG and PG2, I would always revisit PG for the nostalgia hit... which would near instantly wear off once you actually play it. And then I put that game right back down.
PG2 is the game I would revisit, and then actually play and replay extensively. PG2 also had a lot of extra content, which Panzer Corps 2 is just starting to roll out.
That said, some PG2 campaigns were very underwhelming. I think the Soviet campaign was like 6 scenarios? Imagine if Panzer Corps 2 shipped with Allied campaigns of that length. I think people would be more mad than not having them at all, which they already are displeased with.
Honestly, as someone who loved PG1, I've always found the way that PG2 (and also Pacific General which had similar problems) got praised kind of confusing. Like I've said elsewhere, bad AI is one thing, but the AI literally not moving its artillery at all is a game-breaker as it makes the AI incapable of sustaining an offensive. Did everyone just play multi-player and not play against the AI? Also, PG2 had a few too many puzzler-like "reach objective X by turn Y" missions where it felt like the AI was AFK.
What was the problem with PG3? I remember reading people complaining about the AI moves being scripted but this doesn't seem like such a problem.
Re: Panzer Corps 2 vs Panzer Corps 1
People's General was truy awesome and I loved, even if I'll admit that you have a point about the low-unit density and the feeling that you were essentially playing a puzzler game rather than a wargame (I think the biggest difference between the two is whether enemy attacks are ever actually a worry). I agree that it's much better when you're playing across a broad front with different concerns to balance: the Norway map in PG1 remains the gold-standard as far as I am concerned, closely followed by the Korean War map in TOAW.RandomAttack wrote: ↑Wed Aug 26, 2020 3:44 pmAs I remember (OLD memories!), my main issue with PG3 & Peoples General were very low unit densities. Really brought out the puzzle game aspect, since you had so few units there really wasn't much of an option to win using different tactics. Kinda like playing tic-tac-toe as far as tactical options. While my memories are vague, I didn't care for any of the sequels after PG2 (and I bought them all).FOARP wrote: ↑Wed Aug 26, 2020 11:20 amYeah, weren't the UK and US campaigns basically the same just with different voice-acting in PG2?Kerensky wrote: ↑Tue Aug 18, 2020 8:08 pm Panzer Corps definitely feels more like Panzer General.
Panzer Corps 2 feels more like Panzer General 2.
Personally, I am totally on board with this.
Years ago when I was actively playing PG and PG2, I would always revisit PG for the nostalgia hit... which would near instantly wear off once you actually play it. And then I put that game right back down.
PG2 is the game I would revisit, and then actually play and replay extensively. PG2 also had a lot of extra content, which Panzer Corps 2 is just starting to roll out.
That said, some PG2 campaigns were very underwhelming. I think the Soviet campaign was like 6 scenarios? Imagine if Panzer Corps 2 shipped with Allied campaigns of that length. I think people would be more mad than not having them at all, which they already are displeased with.
Honestly, as someone who loved PG1, I've always found the way that PG2 (and also Pacific General which had similar problems) got praised kind of confusing. Like I've said elsewhere, bad AI is one thing, but the AI literally not moving its artillery at all is a game-breaker as it makes the AI incapable of sustaining an offensive. Did everyone just play multi-player and not play against the AI? Also, PG2 had a few too many puzzler-like "reach objective X by turn Y" missions where it felt like the AI was AFK.
What was the problem with PG3? I remember reading people complaining about the AI moves being scripted but this doesn't seem like such a problem.