The Spring Clash Tournament is over - it's time for PAYBACK!

[Shards]

I don't suppose either of you took a screenshot of the last turn?

No, sorry Shards. HJB lost this game because Vp was -18 in this 21st day.

Ahh! Took a few too many losses then!

Yeah, as the Axis, you can't go giving away your high strength tank units in the early game

[Capote]

I don't suppose either of you took a screenshot of the last turn?

No, sorry Shards. HJB lost this game because Vp was -18 in this 21st day.

Ahh! Took a few too many losses then!

Yeah, as the Axis, you can't go giving away your high strength tank units in the early game

I'm sorry, Axis Vp was less of 18, not -18
Edit: My score is bad calculated in the overall score table. Now is 45 when it should be 58 (34 + 24).

[Shards]

ahh, I understand on the score now, didn't realise you were quite so far into the game!

Day by Day Victory thresholds:

Bulge Scores.jpg (89.39 KiB) Viewed 149863 times

I'll investigate what's happening with your scores Capote

Thanks

[Gerifonte]

Apparently all are wrong i think . For example :

COLHoneyBadger 32* 39 59*


Should not be 71 instead of 59 ?

[Shards]

Apparently all are wrong i think . For example :

COLHoneyBadger 32* 39 59*


Should not be 71 instead of 59 ?

Indeed! Some system is failing it's Mathematics degree... we'll get it fixed

[Shards]

Looks like this is fixed now!

[Gerifonte]

shards, Could you review my game with (Allied) vs KenRichards (German).
This game has disappeared from my list of games. I think it probably was because KenRichards he has not sent his turn in more than a day and the game is over in time. But I have not received end-of-game warning mail.This clearly hurt me as I was going to get more points in my favor in the next turns.
Is not it supposed that if a player loses his time he compensates his opponent?

[Shards]

shards, Could you review my game with (Allied) vs KenRichards (German).
This game has disappeared from my list of games. I think it probably was because KenRichards he has not sent his turn in more than a day and the game is over. But I have not received end-of-game warning mail.This clearly hurt me as I was going to get more points in my favor in the next turns.
Is not it supposed that if a player loses his time he compensates his opponent?

187 turns?? Wow!

The 9-11 score on the scoreboard implies to me that you got to the last day (the 28th?). It looks like Ken got a last-day points victory (there's no draws in Bulge, see the graph above), but it may also have timed out, I'll check.

Either way, for games where both players have put in such a monumental effort (srsly, 187 turns!), then we don't do any points penalising as it's obvious that the game was being playing in a good spirit. This is the same for scott1957 and Rodrc2016 where their game 1 ended in a time out but after 151 turns!

Contrast to Duncanrice and PanzerPat's 2nd game where some points have been moved as it timed out on turn 59 (the current cap is at 100 turns, but I'm reviewing that constantly based on evidence from the games you guys are playing).

Thanks,

[Gerifonte]

shards, Could you review my game with (Allied) vs KenRichards (German).
This game has disappeared from my list of games. I think it probably was because KenRichards he has not sent his turn in more than a day and the game is over. But I have not received end-of-game warning mail.This clearly hurt me as I was going to get more points in my favor in the next turns.
Is not it supposed that if a player loses his time he compensates his opponent?

187 turns?? Wow!

The 9-11 score on the scoreboard implies to me that you got to the last day (the 28th?). It looks like Ken got a last-day points victory (there's no draws in Bulge, see the graph above), but it may also have timed out, I'll check.

Either way, for games where both players have put in such a monumental effort (srsly, 187 turns!), then we don't do any points penalising as it's obvious that the game was being playing in a good spirit. This is the same for scott1957 and Rodrc2016 where their game 1 ended in a time out but after 151 turns!

Contrast to Duncanrice and PanzerPat's 2nd game where some points have been moved as it timed out on turn 59 (the current cap is at 100 turns, but I'm reviewing that constantly based on evidence from the games you guys are playing).

Thanks,

No, we were on turn 25 and in play.
And on this turn two units of German cars disappeared with the consequent points for me.
I do not think it would be over for points. Although I can not assure you by not remembering how the punctuation was going.

[Shards]

shards, Could you review my game with (Allied) vs KenRichards (German).
This game has disappeared from my list of games. I think it probably was because KenRichards he has not sent his turn in more than a day and the game is over. But I have not received end-of-game warning mail.This clearly hurt me as I was going to get more points in my favor in the next turns.
Is not it supposed that if a player loses his time he compensates his opponent?

187 turns?? Wow!

The 9-11 score on the scoreboard implies to me that you got to the last day (the 28th?). It looks like Ken got a last-day points victory (there's no draws in Bulge, see the graph above), but it may also have timed out, I'll check.

Either way, for games where both players have put in such a monumental effort (srsly, 187 turns!), then we don't do any points penalising as it's obvious that the game was being playing in a good spirit. This is the same for scott1957 and Rodrc2016 where their game 1 ended in a time out but after 151 turns!

Contrast to Duncanrice and PanzerPat's 2nd game where some points have been moved as it timed out on turn 59 (the current cap is at 100 turns, but I'm reviewing that constantly based on evidence from the games you guys are playing).

Thanks,

No, we were on turn 25 and in play.
And on this turn two units of German cars disappeared with the consequent points for me.
I do not think it would be over for points. Although I can not assure you by not remembering how the punctuation was going.

Hmm, without having the developer to hand to tell me exactly the algorithm for how in-play points are calculated (he's not available until next week). Then I can't really give you any satisfaction I'm afraid! Were you the Axis in this game? Did you win the other game as the Allies?
Thanks

[Gerifonte]

187 turns?? Wow!

The 9-11 score on the scoreboard implies to me that you got to the last day (the 28th?). It looks like Ken got a last-day points victory (there's no draws in Bulge, see the graph above), but it may also have timed out, I'll check.

Either way, for games where both players have put in such a monumental effort (srsly, 187 turns!), then we don't do any points penalising as it's obvious that the game was being playing in a good spirit. This is the same for scott1957 and Rodrc2016 where their game 1 ended in a time out but after 151 turns!

Contrast to Duncanrice and PanzerPat's 2nd game where some points have been moved as it timed out on turn 59 (the current cap is at 100 turns, but I'm reviewing that constantly based on evidence from the games you guys are playing).

Thanks,


No, we were on turn 25 and in play.
And on this turn two units of German cars disappeared with the consequent points for me.
I do not think it would be over for points. Although I can not assure you by not remembering how the punctuation was going.
Hmm, without having the developer to hand to tell me exactly the algorithm for how in-play points are calculated (he's not available until next week). Then I can't really give you any satisfaction I'm afraid! Were you the Axis in this game? Did you win the other game as the Allies?
Thanks

No I was the ally and KenRichards German.
Had wrapped 3 German panzer units and this turn only two of them were left with a point of force and were going to disappear for lack of supplies.
But at the end of the shift ...

[scott1957]

Shards, no big deal but the last tournament game that timed out is still shown in my current games.
Thx, Scott

[Shards]

Shards, no big deal but the last tournament game that timed out is still shown in my current games.
Thx, Scott

Hi!

Thanks for letting me know. There's a bug in the game client right now where it's not always ditching games that time out. Hopefully it'll go if/when your opponent opens the game next.

If there's still games in people's lists at the end of the tournament, we'll go through and make sure they're deactivated

Ta!

[Gerifonte]

What about mine? Do you know anything?

[Shards]

Hi!

My feeling right now is that the game will stand as it is.

I'll ask the developer when he's back in next week about how exactly points are calculated when a game ends mid-turn like that and I'm also going to see whether it's worth extending the play clocks slightly. But at 187 turns, you've obviously both put a lot into the game. And whilst it's obviously frustrating for you to be so near to getting a chunk more VP's and maybe 2 or 3 more tournament points, I don't think it would be truly fair for us to be changing the result of the match.

Thanks,

[Gerifonte]

Hi!

My feeling right now is that the game will stand as it is.

I'll ask the developer when he's back in next week about how exactly points are calculated when a game ends mid-turn like that and I'm also going to see whether it's worth extending the play clocks slightly. But at 187 turns, you've obviously both put a lot into the game. And whilst it's obviously frustrating for you to be so near to getting a chunk more VP's and maybe 2 or 3 more tournament points, I don't think it would be truly fair for us to be changing the result of the match.

Thanks,

What is clear is that right for me is not ..
Please work so that in future tournaments fix this type of problems.
Many times the championships are decided by little points of difference and lose points due to these issues is not funny ...

[AlbertoC]

Just a heads up guys

We 'll be starting a new tournament immediately after the current one ends.

http://slitherine.com/tournaments/tournaments.asp

Subscriptions are already open so feel free to join! It will start next Friday on June 16th.

[Shards]

And the last game has finished!

http://www.slitherine.com/tournaments/s ... =3&aPage=1



Congrats to Commander Gutalin!!

And huge thanks to everyone for taking part!