Killer Player or Killer Army Competition
Moderators: Slitherine Core, NewRoSoft, FoG PC Moderator
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 1029
- Joined: Sat Jan 09, 2010 7:01 pm
- Location: Gatwick, UK
Killer Player or Killer Army Competition
KILLER LEADERBOARD
RISE OF ROME
Mid Republican Roman – 2 games left
Pyrrhic – 2 games left
Later Carthaginian - tiavals
Later Seleucid - tiavals
Later Ptolemaic – 2 games left
STORM OF ARROWS
HYW English - aristides
War Roses Lancastrian – 1 game left
War Roses Yorkist – 1 game left
Medieval Welsh - tiavals
Free Company – 7 games left
Swiss – 4 games left
IMMORTAL FIRE
Later Hoplite Greek – 2 games left
Early Achaemenid Persian – flatsix518
Late Achaemenid Persian – 2 games left
Galatian - ferb
Classical Spartan - aristides
SWORDS AND SCIMITARS
Later Crusader – 1 game left
Seljuk Turk – 1 game left
Mamluk Egyptian – 1 game left
RISE OF ROME
Mid Republican Roman – 2 games left
Pyrrhic – 2 games left
Later Carthaginian - tiavals
Later Seleucid - tiavals
Later Ptolemaic – 2 games left
STORM OF ARROWS
HYW English - aristides
War Roses Lancastrian – 1 game left
War Roses Yorkist – 1 game left
Medieval Welsh - tiavals
Free Company – 7 games left
Swiss – 4 games left
IMMORTAL FIRE
Later Hoplite Greek – 2 games left
Early Achaemenid Persian – flatsix518
Late Achaemenid Persian – 2 games left
Galatian - ferb
Classical Spartan - aristides
SWORDS AND SCIMITARS
Later Crusader – 1 game left
Seljuk Turk – 1 game left
Mamluk Egyptian – 1 game left
Last edited by petergarnett on Sun Feb 05, 2012 7:56 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 1029
- Joined: Sat Jan 09, 2010 7:01 pm
- Location: Gatwick, UK
Competition Armies with players noted
RISE OF ROME
1 Mid Republican Roman (later) – GrudgeBringer, Flatsix518, Jonno, Fedem, BurinusAgricolae
2 Gallic (later lowland) - deleted
3 Pyrrhic – porsenna, Tullius, Gazxtrix, Fedem
4 Later Carthaginian (post 235) – Tiavals, Flatsix518, Gazxtrix, Steve-h8
5 Bosporan - deleted
6 Parthian - deleted
7 Later Seleucid (pre 166) – Tiavals, Jonno, Turk1964, BurinusAgricolae
8 Later Ptolemaic (greek) – Ferb, GrudgeBringer, Tullius, Turk1964
STORM OF ARROWS
1 HYW English (continental early) – iandavidsmith, Fedem, Tullius, Aristides
2 War Roses Lancastrian - Flatsix518, Gazxtrix, Turk1964
3 War Roses Yorkist – stockwellpete, Jonno, iandavidsmith, sharkall, BurinusAgricolae,
Aristides LIST FULL
4 Medieval Welsh – Tiavals, BillMc, Tullius, Turk1964, BurinusAgricolae, stockwellpete LIST FULL
5 Free Company – Tiavals, porsenna, Ferb, Sharkall, GrudgeBringer, Jonno LIST FULL
6 Swiss – Ferb, GrudgeBringer, Flatsix518, Gazxtrix
7 Condotta Milan - deleted
8 Medieval Castilian - deleted
IMMORTAL FIRE
1 Later Hoplite Greek – Fedem, Gazxtrix, Aristides, Tiavals
2 Early Achaemenid Persian (Platea) - Flatsix518, Tullius, Gazxtrix
3 Late Achaemenid Persian – Tiavals, Flatsix518, Jonno
4 Ipsos Alliance Successor – Jonno, Turk1964
5 Galatian – Ferb, GrudgeBringer, Tullius
6 Saka - deleted
7 Classical Indian - deleted
8 Classical Spartan – porsenna, Ferb, GrudgeBringer, Aristides
SWORDS AND SCIMITARS
1 Later Crusader - Flatsix518, GrudgeBringer, Tullius, Stockwellpete, Turk1964
2 Seljuk Turk (Rum) – Fedem, Tullius, Tiavals
3 Nikaian Byzantine - deleted
4 Middle Bulgarian - deleted
5 Mamluk Egyptian – Tiavals, GrudgeBringer, Turk1964, Aristides
6 Khwarazmian - deleted
7 Ayyubid Egyptian (later) - deleted
8 Komnenan Byzantine (later) - deleted
1 Mid Republican Roman (later) – GrudgeBringer, Flatsix518, Jonno, Fedem, BurinusAgricolae
2 Gallic (later lowland) - deleted
3 Pyrrhic – porsenna, Tullius, Gazxtrix, Fedem
4 Later Carthaginian (post 235) – Tiavals, Flatsix518, Gazxtrix, Steve-h8
5 Bosporan - deleted
6 Parthian - deleted
7 Later Seleucid (pre 166) – Tiavals, Jonno, Turk1964, BurinusAgricolae
8 Later Ptolemaic (greek) – Ferb, GrudgeBringer, Tullius, Turk1964
STORM OF ARROWS
1 HYW English (continental early) – iandavidsmith, Fedem, Tullius, Aristides
2 War Roses Lancastrian - Flatsix518, Gazxtrix, Turk1964
3 War Roses Yorkist – stockwellpete, Jonno, iandavidsmith, sharkall, BurinusAgricolae,
Aristides LIST FULL
4 Medieval Welsh – Tiavals, BillMc, Tullius, Turk1964, BurinusAgricolae, stockwellpete LIST FULL
5 Free Company – Tiavals, porsenna, Ferb, Sharkall, GrudgeBringer, Jonno LIST FULL
6 Swiss – Ferb, GrudgeBringer, Flatsix518, Gazxtrix
7 Condotta Milan - deleted
8 Medieval Castilian - deleted
IMMORTAL FIRE
1 Later Hoplite Greek – Fedem, Gazxtrix, Aristides, Tiavals
2 Early Achaemenid Persian (Platea) - Flatsix518, Tullius, Gazxtrix
3 Late Achaemenid Persian – Tiavals, Flatsix518, Jonno
4 Ipsos Alliance Successor – Jonno, Turk1964
5 Galatian – Ferb, GrudgeBringer, Tullius
6 Saka - deleted
7 Classical Indian - deleted
8 Classical Spartan – porsenna, Ferb, GrudgeBringer, Aristides
SWORDS AND SCIMITARS
1 Later Crusader - Flatsix518, GrudgeBringer, Tullius, Stockwellpete, Turk1964
2 Seljuk Turk (Rum) – Fedem, Tullius, Tiavals
3 Nikaian Byzantine - deleted
4 Middle Bulgarian - deleted
5 Mamluk Egyptian – Tiavals, GrudgeBringer, Turk1964, Aristides
6 Khwarazmian - deleted
7 Ayyubid Egyptian (later) - deleted
8 Komnenan Byzantine (later) - deleted
Last edited by petergarnett on Sun Feb 05, 2012 7:46 pm, edited 5 times in total.
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 1029
- Joined: Sat Jan 09, 2010 7:01 pm
- Location: Gatwick, UK
Players with Armies
PLAYERS – Victory Points accrued for each army in brackets
Aristides WotR Yorkist (10, 11, 21, 13), Later Hoplite Greek (22, 18, 12),
Classical Spartan (23, 24, 23), HYW English (21, 19, 18, 21),
Mamluk Egyptian (22, 16, 17)
BillMc Medieval Castilian, Medieval Welsh (27, 24, 22, 22, 15)
BurinusAgricolae Later Seleucid (19, 9, 20), Mid Republican Roman (12, 19, ,
WotR Yorkist (20, 17, 12, 14, 21), Medieval Welsh (15, 14, 23, 24, 24)
Fedem Mid Republican Roman (22, 21, 14, 21), HYW English (11, 23, 10),
Later Hoplite Greek (23, 26), Seljuk Turk (19)
Ferb Free Company (18, 16, 12), Swiss (21, 10, 9), Classical Spartan (23, 24, 16),
Galatian (22, 27), Later Ptolemaic (22, 12), Bosporan, Pyrrhic (19)
Flatsix518 Mid Republican Roman (22, 20, 11, 19), Later Carthaginian (14, 24, 23),
WotR Lancastrian (20), Swiss (18), Early Achaemenid Persian (22, 28),
Late Achaemenid Persian (24), Later Crusader (22, 11, 9), Nikaian Byzantine
Gazxtrix Later Carthaginian (14, 13, 17), Pyrrhic (23, 21), WotR Lancastrian (19),
Swiss, Later Hoplite Greek (26), Early Achaemenid Persian (3, 23)
GrudgeBringer Free Company (3), Swiss (8), Later Ptolemaic (19),
Mid Republican Roman (12, 10), Galatian (20, 6),
Classical Spartan (10, 8, 13), Mamluk Egyptian (5, 5),
Later Crusader (9, 6, 17)
iandavidsmith HYW English (21, 6, 9), WotR Yorkist (11, 7, 22, 15, 21)
Jonno Mid Republican Roman (14, 22, 14), Later Seleucid (18, 15, ,
WotR Yorkist (12, 12, 8, 10), Free Company (17), Late Achaemenid Persian,
Ipsos Alliance Successor
Porsenna Classical Spartan (15, 20, 12), Pyrrhic (19, 9, 1), Free Company (5, 3, 6)
Sharkall Free Company (19, 8, 19, 18, 21), WotR Yorkist (24, 21, 26, 26, 21)
Steve-h8 Later Carthaginian (9, 14, 24), Gallic
Stockwellpete WotR Yorkist (16, 18, 21, 11, 18), Medieval Welsh (9, 22, 23, 24, 16),
Later Crusader (22, 19, 19, 21)
Tiavals Later Carthaginian (25, 21, 24), Later Seleucid (20, 22, 22),
Medieval Welsh (25, 23, 24, 24, 17), Free Company (22, 16, 21),
Late Achaemenid Persian 17), Later Hoplite Greek (24, 25), Seljuk Turk (19),
Mamluk Egyptian (18, 18, 12)
Tullius Pyrrhic (18, 9), Later Ptolemaic (9, 16), Medieval Welsh (8, 19, 11, 19, 22),
HYW English (10, 18, 7), Early Achaemenid Persian (7, 9), Galatian (3, 18),
Later Crusader (9, 19, 3, 16), Seljuk Turk (12, 10)
Turk1964 Medieval Welsh (23, 20, 18, 8, 15), Later Ptolemaic (21, 23, 23),
Later Seleucid (10, 16, 22), WotR Lancastrian (11, 4),
Ipsos Alliance Successor, Mamluk Egyptian (9, 4),
Later Crusader (13, 18, 21, 20)
Aristides WotR Yorkist (10, 11, 21, 13), Later Hoplite Greek (22, 18, 12),
Classical Spartan (23, 24, 23), HYW English (21, 19, 18, 21),
Mamluk Egyptian (22, 16, 17)
BillMc Medieval Castilian, Medieval Welsh (27, 24, 22, 22, 15)
BurinusAgricolae Later Seleucid (19, 9, 20), Mid Republican Roman (12, 19, ,
WotR Yorkist (20, 17, 12, 14, 21), Medieval Welsh (15, 14, 23, 24, 24)
Fedem Mid Republican Roman (22, 21, 14, 21), HYW English (11, 23, 10),
Later Hoplite Greek (23, 26), Seljuk Turk (19)
Ferb Free Company (18, 16, 12), Swiss (21, 10, 9), Classical Spartan (23, 24, 16),
Galatian (22, 27), Later Ptolemaic (22, 12), Bosporan, Pyrrhic (19)
Flatsix518 Mid Republican Roman (22, 20, 11, 19), Later Carthaginian (14, 24, 23),
WotR Lancastrian (20), Swiss (18), Early Achaemenid Persian (22, 28),
Late Achaemenid Persian (24), Later Crusader (22, 11, 9), Nikaian Byzantine
Gazxtrix Later Carthaginian (14, 13, 17), Pyrrhic (23, 21), WotR Lancastrian (19),
Swiss, Later Hoplite Greek (26), Early Achaemenid Persian (3, 23)
GrudgeBringer Free Company (3), Swiss (8), Later Ptolemaic (19),
Mid Republican Roman (12, 10), Galatian (20, 6),
Classical Spartan (10, 8, 13), Mamluk Egyptian (5, 5),
Later Crusader (9, 6, 17)
iandavidsmith HYW English (21, 6, 9), WotR Yorkist (11, 7, 22, 15, 21)
Jonno Mid Republican Roman (14, 22, 14), Later Seleucid (18, 15, ,
WotR Yorkist (12, 12, 8, 10), Free Company (17), Late Achaemenid Persian,
Ipsos Alliance Successor
Porsenna Classical Spartan (15, 20, 12), Pyrrhic (19, 9, 1), Free Company (5, 3, 6)
Sharkall Free Company (19, 8, 19, 18, 21), WotR Yorkist (24, 21, 26, 26, 21)
Steve-h8 Later Carthaginian (9, 14, 24), Gallic
Stockwellpete WotR Yorkist (16, 18, 21, 11, 18), Medieval Welsh (9, 22, 23, 24, 16),
Later Crusader (22, 19, 19, 21)
Tiavals Later Carthaginian (25, 21, 24), Later Seleucid (20, 22, 22),
Medieval Welsh (25, 23, 24, 24, 17), Free Company (22, 16, 21),
Late Achaemenid Persian 17), Later Hoplite Greek (24, 25), Seljuk Turk (19),
Mamluk Egyptian (18, 18, 12)
Tullius Pyrrhic (18, 9), Later Ptolemaic (9, 16), Medieval Welsh (8, 19, 11, 19, 22),
HYW English (10, 18, 7), Early Achaemenid Persian (7, 9), Galatian (3, 18),
Later Crusader (9, 19, 3, 16), Seljuk Turk (12, 10)
Turk1964 Medieval Welsh (23, 20, 18, 8, 15), Later Ptolemaic (21, 23, 23),
Later Seleucid (10, 16, 22), WotR Lancastrian (11, 4),
Ipsos Alliance Successor, Mamluk Egyptian (9, 4),
Later Crusader (13, 18, 21, 20)
Last edited by petergarnett on Sun Feb 05, 2012 7:45 pm, edited 8 times in total.
-
- Lieutenant Colonel - Elite Panther D
- Posts: 1379
- Joined: Tue Dec 15, 2009 11:56 am
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14500
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
Being very new, I was wondering if the armies you have chosen for the 2 expansions you have listed are:
1. Random (more or less)
2. What you feel are the top 8 armies in strength
3. The top 8 armies at 350 points in strenth (I expect that would be a HUGE factor)
The reason I ask is that I have all but the last 2 expansions and of course I can't play all the armies (even if I did against the AI it wouldn't do much for me). Sooooo, if these are the consensus for the top armies in the 'book', I can look into those armies.
Thanks!!
1. Random (more or less)
2. What you feel are the top 8 armies in strength
3. The top 8 armies at 350 points in strenth (I expect that would be a HUGE factor)
The reason I ask is that I have all but the last 2 expansions and of course I can't play all the armies (even if I did against the AI it wouldn't do much for me). Sooooo, if these are the consensus for the top armies in the 'book', I can look into those armies.
Thanks!!
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14500
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
I think this is a very interesting question. I think Peter has probably gone for what he regards as some of the strongest armies in the two books, but also he has chosen armies that are quite popular. The SOA list is quite impressive, but I think strong cases could also be made for the Anglo-Irish and Santa Hermandad Nueva Castilians if you were going solely for the strongest armies - and maybe the Medieval Welsh and Milanese Condotta might be the ones to make way. But, irrespective of this, the SOA list that Peter has come up with is a very interesting one.GrudgeBringer wrote:Being very new, I was wondering if the armies you have chosen for the 2 expansions you have listed are:
1. Random (more or less)
2. What you feel are the top 8 armies in strength
3. The top 8 armies at 350 points in strenth (I expect that would be a HUGE factor)
The reason I ask is that I have all but the last 2 expansions and of course I can't play all the armies (even if I did against the AI it wouldn't do much for me). Sooooo, if these are the consensus for the top armies in the 'book', I can look into those armies.
Thanks!!
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 1029
- Joined: Sat Jan 09, 2010 7:01 pm
- Location: Gatwick, UK
Thanks for the replies so far.
Answers to some of the questions:-
Choice of armies - it's subjective of course but the clue is in the competion title - I've tried to include both popular armies which 'appear' to be killers and less common ones where perhaps, & again it's just my opinion, more skill is needed to win consistantly. Plus some of my own favs are in there!
350 points was deliberate - I think it gives a faster result, uses less commonly seen maps, & in conjection with the victory points makes for more of a challenge.
You can enter as many expansions as you want but only two armies in any particular expansion, so 2 from RoR, 2 from SoA, 2 from DF etc.
Posting the armies from the next 2 expansions shortly.
However we'll need more players to make this competition viable.
As for the start date - it's as soon as we have 3 players opting for the same army.
Answers to some of the questions:-
Choice of armies - it's subjective of course but the clue is in the competion title - I've tried to include both popular armies which 'appear' to be killers and less common ones where perhaps, & again it's just my opinion, more skill is needed to win consistantly. Plus some of my own favs are in there!
350 points was deliberate - I think it gives a faster result, uses less commonly seen maps, & in conjection with the victory points makes for more of a challenge.
You can enter as many expansions as you want but only two armies in any particular expansion, so 2 from RoR, 2 from SoA, 2 from DF etc.
Posting the armies from the next 2 expansions shortly.
However we'll need more players to make this competition viable.
As for the start date - it's as soon as we have 3 players opting for the same army.
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 1029
- Joined: Sat Jan 09, 2010 7:01 pm
- Location: Gatwick, UK
For each expansion you can play upto two armies.
If you've not made your selection for an army please do so. I'd rather not decide on behalf of anyone please.
As soon as a particular army has 3 players we can start that part so if you genuinely don't mind which army to play then maybe put your name down for one of those which others have selected so far.
Cheers
If you've not made your selection for an army please do so. I'd rather not decide on behalf of anyone please.
As soon as a particular army has 3 players we can start that part so if you genuinely don't mind which army to play then maybe put your name down for one of those which others have selected so far.
Cheers