Page 1 of 1

Why No Straight Warhammer Simulations?

Posted: Fri Oct 20, 2017 11:12 am
by Cheimison
Warhammer has been RTS, Total War, shooters, RPGs, and MMOs. Why isn't there one damn game that's a direct implementation of the rules, complete with gearing armies and do forth? Warhammer rules are significantly simpler mathematically than real time battles or Crusader Kings or War in the Pacific, so why doesn't this exist? Is GW afraid that nobody will buy their toys if a vastly more convenient digital option existed?
I ask here because SR is the closest so far, yet inexplicably still not actually Warhammer rules.

Re: Why No Straight Warhammer Simulations?

Posted: Sat Oct 21, 2017 7:48 am
by Parallax
Cause Games Workshop don't want to lose their money they earn by selling models. That's why they forbid direct implementation of their rules

Re: Why No Straight Warhammer Simulations?

Posted: Sun Dec 10, 2017 5:26 am
by veeneman
It seems like it's just a matter of limited resources for the game developer. After a few days playing, I love Sanctus Reach but you can tell it was made on a tight budget... They aren't in the same league as say Fallout 4 for example.

Maybe if they did a Kickstarter...

Re: Why No Straight Warhammer Simulations?

Posted: Wed Dec 13, 2017 12:23 am
by exsonic01
If you really want to something like 40K TT in PC, you can try Vassal or Tabletop simulator. But the feelings of those games are different from real tabletop games, in my opinion.

I agree with kickstarter. This game deserve more investment and budget for better graphic and animations... But right now this game is under Slitherine, and I just wish the proper investment for this franchise.

Re: Why No Straight Warhammer Simulations?

Posted: Tue Apr 03, 2018 4:01 am
by Grimdarc
Have to wait until GW's financial decline is complete and pray it folds rather than sells to something heinous like Hasbro. Unfortunately, the explosion of interest and indie creativity in direct implementation of the TT would incentivize Blizzard or something huge to pickup the IP monopoly.

In the end the reason there isn't TT direct implementation is that too many players want it giving it market value. The same creative indie people above could make their own world with its own cool lore, but if it's really worth playing then it might attract a following. Creative indie smarty types would sell their idea for a payday and pay-to-win would end the cycle.

If too many people want what you want the demand will change the thing into something no one wants eventually.

Re: Why No Straight Warhammer Simulations?

Posted: Tue Jul 17, 2018 7:29 am
by DocDesastro
Maybe they will recognize at some point, that by selling the idea makes more money than the miniatures. I see the future - if any - for GW as a software company dedicated to produce rules, models and background to sell and to have a computer version of their boardgame. Imagine buying the core game thus the game engine. DLCs can be factions or even part of the factions. Like 'Buy the Marines' and you get access to basic marine troops for playing like the tacticals, assault and devastators and Rhinos. Buy veteran DLC and you get access to venerable dreadnoughts, terminators, honor guard units etc. Same frag as today: just charge the customer with ridiculous fees.

Re: Why No Straight Warhammer Simulations?

Posted: Mon Jul 23, 2018 10:56 pm
by Cataphract88
DocDesastro wrote:
Tue Jul 17, 2018 7:29 am
Maybe they will recognize at some point, that by selling the idea makes more money than the miniatures. I see the future - if any - for GW as a software company dedicated to produce rules, models and background to sell and to have a computer version of their boardgame. Imagine buying the core game thus the game engine. DLCs can be factions or even part of the factions. Like 'Buy the Marines' and you get access to basic marine troops for playing like the tacticals, assault and devastators and Rhinos. Buy veteran DLC and you get access to venerable dreadnoughts, terminators, honor guard units etc. Same frag as today: just charge the customer with ridiculous fees.
Don't put ideas into their heads - they're bad enough already! :roll:

Re: Why No Straight Warhammer Simulations?

Posted: Tue Jul 24, 2018 3:48 pm
by DocDesastro
Meh...I guess they have those ideas already. Currently, it is more profitable to produce a plastic kit for less than 10 cents apiece and sell for 30$ and more. But I think a bit into the future. 3D-printers might be available for private persons so printing your own miniatures under license might be something or they go full software version with customizable models and unlocking factions as DLCs. I mean...there ARE possibilities...but currently? License every 40k game no matter how good or bad and make a fortune worldwide with overpriced miniatures.