nikgaukroger wrote: Control would be with the last legitimate controlling unit in contact with the dummy base - rules would need to specify this in some form.
Thats exactly the point I'm making. You'd need to define "last legitimate controlling unit"
1) So, I move up to artillery and capture it with some horse, who then move to sit partly on top of it, as it's now "mine" but "uncontrolled"
2) I then move some foot into edge contact with it, so it becomes "controlled" but is still being interpenetrated by my horse - who can't now technically interpenetrate it,
2a) so are they now stuck there?
2b) Can the artillery now shoot?
2c) Could enemy horse charge my horse if to do so they have to charge across the marker which is now technically my artillery?
2c and a bit) Or would an enemy charge stop at the point it contacts the artillery, rendering the artillery uncontrolled but not "mine" - or, if they were foot, possibly even meaning that my horse might find themeleves interpenetrating enemy artillery?
Or, following straight on from 2) Assuming My foot move off but my horse stay on the artillery ...
3) I move up a second unit of horse into contact with what is now "my" "controlled" artillery, but is still a marker due to the first unit of horse. Can the new unit go onto the marker or not?
4) Someone attacks my first unit of horse by contacting bases, or more likley, base edges, which are not overlapping the artillery, and breaks them. What happens to the artillery then - is it uncontrolled, recaptured immediately, or only when the enemy actually contacts the markers (which are actually bases)..?
aaarrgh!
(says the man who still suspects "remove if contacted by folks who cant capture it" is going to be easier)