Ancient Spanish Scutarii BG's
Moderators: terrys, hammy, philqw78, Slitherine Core, Field of Glory Moderators, Field of Glory Design
-
- Lance Corporal - Panzer IA
- Posts: 15
- Joined: Fri Jan 30, 2009 8:58 am
- Contact:
Ancient Spanish Scutarii BG's
I'm putting together an Iberian centric army and was wondering about warband size. What has been your experience with undrilled BG sizes? I'm currently leaning towards BG's of 10.
-
- Corporal - Strongpoint
- Posts: 55
- Joined: Thu Apr 16, 2009 9:33 pm
You want some third-rankers for a BG that is going into the line of battle a head-up fight against something challenging, which practically means 8s, though there is something to be said for having one very large BG to play with (more so with HF that stand in the open). 6 undrilled bases will do well for a second line support/reserve or for chasing lights or vulnerable mediums out of terrain - in a Gallic list with lots of HF I take the Spanish ally with a pair of 6s to clear terrain and some LH for utility.
Mike
Mike
-
- Field Marshal - Elefant
- Posts: 5875
- Joined: Tue Jan 22, 2008 1:44 am
- Location: Southern Ontario, Canada
Try various groupings and see what you like. The Celtiberian HF work well in 10s (4-4-2) or 8s (3-3-2). The 10s have the benefit of needing 4 hits to cause a CT. Two of these BGs side by side, with a 6pak for rear support, make the best centre block the Spanish can muster. I usually run each 10pak of Celtiberians with an ally commander. They need all the help they can get, esp. if facing Romans or Pikes. Ancient Spanish is one of the few lists that can use those ally commanders.
The MF, if undrilled, are better kept small and numerous. I've found they can be very unwieldy if in 8s. Generals are a must, IC if you can. Otherwise, we've seen an entire flank hang up on itself.
Try the drilled 4paks sometime. Now that's a swarm!!!!
The MF, if undrilled, are better kept small and numerous. I've found they can be very unwieldy if in 8s. Generals are a must, IC if you can. Otherwise, we've seen an entire flank hang up on itself.
Try the drilled 4paks sometime. Now that's a swarm!!!!
-
- Corporal - Strongpoint
- Posts: 54
- Joined: Wed Nov 18, 2009 10:49 am
- Location: Vancouver BC Canada
-
- Lance Corporal - Panzer IA
- Posts: 15
- Joined: Fri Jan 30, 2009 8:58 am
- Contact:
-
- Field Marshal - Elefant
- Posts: 5875
- Joined: Tue Jan 22, 2008 1:44 am
- Location: Southern Ontario, Canada
-
- Field Marshal - Me 410A
- Posts: 5000
- Joined: Mon Oct 20, 2008 12:41 am
The Sertorius list with drilled BG's gives the Spanish their best chance of winning in my opinion. Now if you can find some very rare and simple type of Roman player who will not use vet legions superior skilled swords, and uses average swords for his legions you would have a much better chance with the Spanish. Unfortunately it is unlikely any Roman will not take the superior skilled sword killing machine.
Depends on whether it is a tournament player who only wants to win or a player who likes historical and plausible match-ups.Unfortunately it is unlikely any Roman will not take the superior skilled sword killing machine.
Besides, some Romans can't be all superior, skilled swordsmen like the MRR, who can only field 16 bases of these.
-
- Corporal - Strongpoint
- Posts: 54
- Joined: Wed Nov 18, 2009 10:49 am
- Location: Vancouver BC Canada
-
- Corporal - Strongpoint
- Posts: 54
- Joined: Wed Nov 18, 2009 10:49 am
- Location: Vancouver BC Canada
Sorry my bad, that should have read 27 bases not BGs, bit hungover, buddies Birthday last night. He turned 30 we tried to kill him with booze.
Here's how my math should have worked.
Caetrati are usually 6-8 per BG and 12-110 bases, with the upgrade they become 4-6 per BG with the bases requirements field stating "any", which I assume (in my near boundless ignorance) remains 12-110. Divide 110 by 4 you get 27 bases, with 4 packs you can field 6 BGs of these little monsters.
Thanks for calling me on that, my math always sucks.
Here's how my math should have worked.
Caetrati are usually 6-8 per BG and 12-110 bases, with the upgrade they become 4-6 per BG with the bases requirements field stating "any", which I assume (in my near boundless ignorance) remains 12-110. Divide 110 by 4 you get 27 bases, with 4 packs you can field 6 BGs of these little monsters.
Thanks for calling me on that, my math always sucks.
-
- Field Marshal - Elefant
- Posts: 5875
- Joined: Tue Jan 22, 2008 1:44 am
- Location: Southern Ontario, Canada
Sertorius is with the Lusitanians...you have to use that section of the list...Heavy Caetrati 16-48 bases...any/all of which can be upgraded to the drilled 4-6 paks. They can also have the large shield cav and the small shield cav and the caetrati LF from the top of the list...plus Celtiberian mercenaries or allies make a good center of HF...I know some like to toss in the two 4paks of Romans
-
- Field Marshal - Me 410A
- Posts: 5000
- Joined: Mon Oct 20, 2008 12:41 am
I think everyones just in the '4 pak swarm' mentality at the moment, 4 packs of average impact foot i cant see being that great, testing to not charge, only needing to take two casualties to auto-break, really not as good as the roman equivalent that everyones so hyped up about.
If I was going to run Ancient Spanish, I'd probably run it like this.
Ancient Spanish - Sertorius' Lusitanians
1x Inspired commander - Inspired commander holds the main battle line against enemy foot armies (ones that line up and charge), or helps the probably
2x Troop commanders - skirmishers out against enemy shoot armies to stop them from losing cohesion to enemy shooting (umbrella effect), the two troop commanders would attach to the two units that are fighting the most in an effort to hold them or even get them to win.
12x Mercenary Celtibarians - These two units are the main force that can provide a large frontage and should be able to hold out until other units can help,
12x Mercenary Celtibarians - heavy foot helps against the enemy cavalry. These would either deploy in 5 wide or 6 wide depending on the need to replenish casualties or provide a larger frontage.
6x Heavy Caetrati - These five units are all drilled, one provides rear support for the heavy foot (being drilled it makes it easier to stay in rear support
6x Heavy Caetrati - range/position), the other four units hold the flanks and turn the enemies flanks.
6x Heavy Caetrati
6x Heavy Caetrati
6x Heavy Caetrati
6x Caetrati - These three units are shooting soakers, and can chase away enemy light foot if needed, the unit of eight is the one you put into the position
6x Caetrati - to soak the most fire, or if needed to hold a unit of bow armed light horse (even poa, even dice in melee) until help arrives.
8x Caetrati
4x Large shield cav (drilled) - These five units are anti-skirmishers mostly, can take out enemy light horse and light foot, and the large shield cav can add
4x Small shield cav - that element of shock power onto a flank of an enemy unit if they choose to ignore them. The slingers are there to help shoot enemy
4x Small shield cav - light horse and stick close enough to the light horse so that they shouldnt be vulnerable to enemy light horse running them down.
4x Small shield cav
6x Slingers
Order of march would be:
1. Caetrati 2. Large shield cavalry 3. Heavy Caetrati 4. Mercenaries
1. Caetrati 2. Small shield cavalry 3. Heavy Caetrati 4. Mercenaries
1. Caetrati 2. Small shield cavalry 3. Heavy Caetrati 4. Rear support Heavy Caetrati
1. Slingers 2. Small shield cavalry 3. Heavy Caetrati
You leave the mercenaries until last and plonk them down in front of the main body of enemy infantry, move them up slowly when you know that your Heavy Caetrati will be able to support/envelop the flanks by the time you get into contact, or a maximum of two turns afterwards. The cavalry/slingers attack enemy light horse or slow down one flank of enemy forces, depending on the enemy. The caetrati can either support the skirmishers, slow down the other flank, or soak fire for the mercenaries.
If I was going to run Ancient Spanish, I'd probably run it like this.
Ancient Spanish - Sertorius' Lusitanians
1x Inspired commander - Inspired commander holds the main battle line against enemy foot armies (ones that line up and charge), or helps the probably
2x Troop commanders - skirmishers out against enemy shoot armies to stop them from losing cohesion to enemy shooting (umbrella effect), the two troop commanders would attach to the two units that are fighting the most in an effort to hold them or even get them to win.
12x Mercenary Celtibarians - These two units are the main force that can provide a large frontage and should be able to hold out until other units can help,
12x Mercenary Celtibarians - heavy foot helps against the enemy cavalry. These would either deploy in 5 wide or 6 wide depending on the need to replenish casualties or provide a larger frontage.
6x Heavy Caetrati - These five units are all drilled, one provides rear support for the heavy foot (being drilled it makes it easier to stay in rear support
6x Heavy Caetrati - range/position), the other four units hold the flanks and turn the enemies flanks.
6x Heavy Caetrati
6x Heavy Caetrati
6x Heavy Caetrati
6x Caetrati - These three units are shooting soakers, and can chase away enemy light foot if needed, the unit of eight is the one you put into the position
6x Caetrati - to soak the most fire, or if needed to hold a unit of bow armed light horse (even poa, even dice in melee) until help arrives.
8x Caetrati
4x Large shield cav (drilled) - These five units are anti-skirmishers mostly, can take out enemy light horse and light foot, and the large shield cav can add
4x Small shield cav - that element of shock power onto a flank of an enemy unit if they choose to ignore them. The slingers are there to help shoot enemy
4x Small shield cav - light horse and stick close enough to the light horse so that they shouldnt be vulnerable to enemy light horse running them down.
4x Small shield cav
6x Slingers
Order of march would be:
1. Caetrati 2. Large shield cavalry 3. Heavy Caetrati 4. Mercenaries
1. Caetrati 2. Small shield cavalry 3. Heavy Caetrati 4. Mercenaries
1. Caetrati 2. Small shield cavalry 3. Heavy Caetrati 4. Rear support Heavy Caetrati
1. Slingers 2. Small shield cavalry 3. Heavy Caetrati
You leave the mercenaries until last and plonk them down in front of the main body of enemy infantry, move them up slowly when you know that your Heavy Caetrati will be able to support/envelop the flanks by the time you get into contact, or a maximum of two turns afterwards. The cavalry/slingers attack enemy light horse or slow down one flank of enemy forces, depending on the enemy. The caetrati can either support the skirmishers, slow down the other flank, or soak fire for the mercenaries.
-
- Field Marshal - Elefant
- Posts: 5875
- Joined: Tue Jan 22, 2008 1:44 am
- Location: Southern Ontario, Canada
-
- Field Marshal - Me 410A
- Posts: 5000
- Joined: Mon Oct 20, 2008 12:41 am
I have played both types of Spanish armies and personally had much better success with the 4pack drilled, which is the real key here not the numbers. Large unwieldy undrilled hordes are no match for the quick moving drilled superior Romans, at least the drilled 4 packs allow you to maneuver onto their flanks and do some damage. Mostly the Spanish clear the flanks where the lights and other fodder are deployed and then lose their center to the Legions while the flank hordes attempt to turn in mostly unsuccessfully while their break points climb and their army break point is reached.
Actual game experience goes further than theoretical army lists
Actual game experience goes further than theoretical army lists
Oh well mate, just trying to help, with an army that I wouldnt want to run in the first place, while keeping it out of the 'cheap' category that people see in 4 packs.. which i also dislike because they take casualties worse, and take shooting worse than the 6 packs do. The drilled medium foot are the hammer, the heavy undrilled foot are the anvil.
-
- Lance Corporal - Panzer IA
- Posts: 15
- Joined: Fri Jan 30, 2009 8:58 am
- Contact:
The Heavy Caetrati argument is a strong one and thanks for the input. I may have to build both just for fun.
Going this direction would require some modelling questions:
If I go that way how would I depict those troops using Corvus?
Typical Caetrati models, just as MF?
Add larger shields replacing small round?
Were the Lusitanians the ones who used the sinew helmet more frequently? I also read somewhere they that they had a fondness for darker weave clothing.
Going this direction would require some modelling questions:
If I go that way how would I depict those troops using Corvus?
Typical Caetrati models, just as MF?
Add larger shields replacing small round?
Were the Lusitanians the ones who used the sinew helmet more frequently? I also read somewhere they that they had a fondness for darker weave clothing.
-
- Sergeant First Class - Elite Panzer IIIL
- Posts: 435
- Joined: Tue Jan 22, 2008 4:53 am