Retreat table not corect ?

[Tigre]

On the retreat table, it says a unit with 2 pips must suffer 2 hits to retreat (it won't take the second one) ...
Well a 2 pips soviet armor (out of 4) retreated on one damage (taking 0 casulaty) !
I suspect that the Battle of the Bulge coding as not been corected for Drive on Moscow ? BotB retreat table says, RH* where DoM says H ...
the reason is maybe something else ?
thx

Tigregarou

[daviddunham]

Did you report that using the Feedback button in the game? Because that gives the specific situation and makes it much easier to visualize.

[Tigre]

Did you report that using the Feedback button in the game? Because that gives the specific situation and makes it much easier to visualize.

not yet, I'm still looking for the game where it hapen, I affraid I deleted it ! anyway asap it occurs again, I'll send feedback !

[Tigre]

sended feedback on this situation, 2 pips soviet inf retreat with no casuaty from a german armor attak ... you received the case 8614 ! let us now what is the outcome ?
thx and congrats again for AI and game improvment

[Ryvin]

I post here to avoid another thread related to retreats issue...


First of all I sent you the feedback of the gamecenter match where the situation occured. Now I explain it: during a soviet prepared offensive (turn 20), an attack in Orel with two axis infantry 9 pips together defending it.
Infantry suffered 5 hits (after terrain reduction of course) and retreat so only 4 hits accounted for. Now, defending in a victory space (such as Orel) give the defender a shift one column on the right of the retreat table and in this case with 5 hits the result is "hold" not 30% chance of retreat (remember the right shift). Am I missing something?

Thank you for answers!!!